Treasure Island - Bristol Old Vic REVIEW

From the moment the overture hit, this Treasure Island delivers a great score with real toe-tapping numbers. The writers Pippa Cleary and Jake Brunger (creators of The Great British Bake Off Musical and The Secret Diary of Adrian Mole Aged 13 3/4) have made sure that there are no weak moments in the musical lineup here. The songs are catchy, spirited, and crafted to keep even the most landlocked audience members tapping like seasoned sailors on deck.

The cast were strong, led by Adryne Caulder-James as Jim Hawkins, whose performance shines brightly throughout. Her vocals and presence bring heart and pluck to the role, proving she’s more than ready to navigate the tricky waters of musical theatre. All the performers bring beautiful voices and impressive instrumental chops, turning the ensemble numbers into a lively sea shanty spectacle.

Local favourite Jayde Adams brings her trademark wit and charm to a host of colourful characters though at times the role feels like it could have dived a little deeper beneath the surface.

Visually, the set is stunning. We’re transported from a cosy Bristol pub (with nods to the Llandoger Trow right down the street) all the way to a fully realised pirate ship and a looming desert island.

Act Two is when the adventure truly catches the wind. The introduction of singing coconuts and skeletons popping up among the audience keeps children engaged and laughing. The show really finds its sea legs here.

That said, the first half felt rather wordy, with exposition that may have weighed anchor for younger viewers, while still feeling a bit too childlike for adults. It left the whole production caught in that tricky space between kiddie fare and grown-up spectacle.

Treasure Island is a swashbuckling adventure that never quite sets sail with the full force of its promise. There’s treasure here, but you might find yourself wanting just a bit more sparkle in the gold.